Rudy the Reluctant New Yorker

There is a large segment of the US population that loves to hate NYC.  I'm pretty sure this is why New York gets destroyed in so many movies.  Audiences love to see monsters, natural disasters, and giant marshmallow men take a crippling bite out of the big apple.  

No one understands this better than Rudy Giuliani.  He's waged his entire campaign war chest on hostility towards New York.  Rudy Giuliani isn't the product of everything wonderful that NYC has to offer, but a fighter who has survived growing up in America's most reviled city and lived to tell the tale.

So it makes sense that Giuliani runs against his hometown.  Last week's New York Magazine takes a close look at how Rudy talks about NYC on the campaign trail.  It's interesting reading, even if you're already familiar with the Giuliani narrative.

Emphasis mine:

The next 45 minutes wander from gushy Ronald Reagan tributes to complicated plans for a 2,000-mile immigrant-repelling border fence to a discourse on the infallibility of the Founding Fathers. Central to it all, though, is Rudy the resolute, the lonely man tough enough to stick selflessly by his convictions, even when they're unpopular, until he's ultimately proved right. And the proof is his glorious success as mayor of the most dangerous, most corrupt, most Democratic city in the land. "Every candidate promises you lots of things," he says. "The most important thing is, can somebody deliver? Can they get something done? Well, here's what I have to offer: I know how to get things done. I did it in the place where it was really hard to do! Nobody, nobody really got anything done in New York about crime, about welfare, about the condition of the streets, about our economy, about bringing jobs to New York! Not only did nobody get anything done for a long time, most people had given up, and they didn't think anything could be done!"

This is a disorienting notion--but the condescending attitude is completely familiar to any New Yorker. The city in the nineties was far from perfect. But were we really living in the hellhole of depravity and despair that Giuliani describes without ever realizing it? And was he the man who single-handedly tamed 8 million misbehaving New Yorkers, delivering us from an economic and physical nightmare? They sure think so out here in the real America: The chants of "Roo-dee! Roo-dee!" are drowning out Giuliani's final words, and women are elbowing one another in pursuit of his autograph.

In Giuliani's speeches the terrorists are coming to get you.  But they're not the only enemy.  The New Yorkers are coming to get you too.  They want to raise your taxes so they can get themselves back on the welfare rolls and lead a life of leisure on your dime.  They want to open the borders so illegal aliens will pour in from every part of the world.  And as strange as this may sound, New York liberals don't understand the importance of national security.  Only Rudy can save us from the terrorists.  Only Rudy can save us from the New Yorkers.

Can you imagine the media frenzy if John Edwards talked about the people of North Carolina with the same level of contempt?  



Display:


Re: Rudy the Reluctant New Yorker (none / 0)

And New Yorkers return the favor.

I lived in New York for 10 years, from early '70s to '82, and as anyone who has lived in the city knows, it has it's drawbacks.

However, I don't hate the city, even though I wouldn't, couldn't, go back. It's a tough city to live in unless you have a lot of money (a big pot of money), and I'd no longer make it through the winters.

But Rudy can't go back, because they'd burn him in effigy.

(And the firefighters might go further than that, with good reason.)

No one who lived under his tenure wants him back, I hate him for what he did to the NYPD and firefighters which resulted in hundreds of their deaths on 9/11.

So Rudy feels free to bash for the New York haters, really the bigots who hate the supposed "liberal values," the city's multiculturalism, the culture, in short.

It's a perfect jewel of hatred for the brown people, homos, free women and intellectuals who reign in New York and Rudy is cheerfully bolstering up the envious yahoos in the hinterlands.


by judybrowni on Sun Dec 09, 2007 at 05:50:16 PM EST

Re: Rudy the Reluctant New Yorker (none / 0)

Speaking of the NYC firefighters, here's a piece of their mind:
http://firefightingnews.com/article-US.c fm?articleID=27125

Interestingly, this comes up on the first page when you google "Giuliani."


by Benicio on Sun Dec 09, 2007 at 06:39:59 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Rudy the Reluctant New Yorker (none / 0)

Giuliani got destroyed on Meet the Press this morning. Question after question about scandals from Kerik through Giuliani Partners working for Huge Chavez to using city funds to escort his mistress around New York. Russert was able to fill up the hour-long show time by simply going from one scandal to the next. It makes you wonder why the guy isn't behind bars, much less how he can be running for president.


by animated on Sun Dec 09, 2007 at 09:07:30 PM EST

Re: Rudy the Reluctant New Yorker (none / 0)

Don't bet against Rudy being indicted at some point over the Judy Nathan police chauffering scandal.  NYS Comptroller Alan Hevesi pleaded guilty to a similar crime and was forced to resign his office early this year.  

It is true the spouse of the Mayor is entitled to police protection but I have never heard of that protection being extended to the Mayor's mistress.  It wouldn't surprise me if the Manhattan DAs office does something with this.


by John Mills on Sun Dec 09, 2007 at 11:16:32 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Rudy the Reluctant New Yorker (none / 0)

Yup, it's an interesting dichotomy. There are those who would probably end their lives if they were told they had to exist outside of NY, NY. And there are many of us who would do just the same if we were told we had to live there.

From a country boy.


by Bob Miller on Sun Dec 09, 2007 at 10:48:09 PM EST

Re: Rudy the Reluctant New Yorker (none / 0)

On 9/10/01, people were glad that Rudy was leaving office.  NYers have returned that view of him and it appears the nation is as well.  NYC residents prefer Mike Bloomberg to Rudy as Mayor by a margin of 46%-16%.  Not exactly the numbers you want when you are running for President.


by John Mills on Sun Dec 09, 2007 at 11:26:18 PM EST

Romney (none / 0)

Mitt Romney's gotten pretty contemptuous of Massachusetts since he changed from governor to presidential candidate.


DC Drinking LiberallyDC for Democracy

by KCinDC on Mon Dec 10, 2007 at 12:46:40 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.